Stored prices by grade and source, exactly as recorded. A source with no price for a grade shows a dash.
Your holding and stored prices
Your cost basis next to the stored PriceCharting price for the grade you hold
Unheld Asset
Portfolio Holdings & Cost-Basis Ledger
Personal Verified Position
No Holding Logged in Portfolio
Track your holding in your portfolio. Record your grade (0.5–10.0 or Raw), grading authority (CGC, CBCS, PSA, or Raw), acquisition cost basis, and purchase date to activate real-time equity valuation, unrealized ROI, and capital gains tracking.
Sovereign Storage: Supabase RLS ProtectedStatus: Unheld
Stored prices
PriceCharting
Grade 9.8 Benchmark
$33.45
Dealer buy: — / Retail sell: —
RAW / Ungraded FMV
$5.40
Dealer buy: $1.20 / Retail sell: $5.89
Market Velocity
—
Original Cover: —
Price history and sales
Dated PriceCharting snapshots and recorded sales. Nothing is drawn where no dated price exists.
Watchlist
Key Prices
SOV Price$33.45
9.8 FMV$33.45
RAW$5.40
24h Δ↑ +354.4%
Grade Spread
10.0
$43.00—
9.8
$33.45—
9.2
$19.01—
8.0
$13.77—
6.0
$9.25—
4.0
$3.38—
3.0
$3.00—
2.0
$2.00—
price · vol
Census Snapshot
1
total graded
1
9.8+
9.8
1
CGC Universal + SS · Oct 2026
Intelligence Feed
No recent stories
AI-scored · tracking Action Comics Annual · refreshes every 2 min
BB20 is waiting for 20 dated prices for 9.8; no shorter window is substituted.
RSI (14) — Relative Strength Index▲
No RSI data for Action Comics Annual
Latest CGC 9.8
$33.45
Oct 6, 2026
Low / high on file
$33.45 / $33.45
since Oct 6, 2026
Dated prices
1
CGC 9.8
NightOwl Market Conditions▲
Fill Probability
88%
4–16 bps slippage
Liquidity
NORMAL
Depth 82 · STABLE
Volatility
NORMAL
1.1% intraday range
Momentum
ACCELERATING
+2.8% · Vol 1.15
Grade Arbitrage
ISSUE
NORMAL
6.2× sovereign premium over raw
Tectonic Pressure
ISSUE
T0 · EQUILIBRIUM
Structural baseline · no active fault shear
Market-wide signal (top 4) · Issue-specific signal (bottom 2 · tagged ISSUE)
Signal SynthesisOpenRouter
Action Comics Annual #12 demonstrates disciplined liquidity depth and stable sovereign grade spread characteristics across current secondary market trading.
Market Sentiment▲
Demand Signal
🔵 HOLD
Holder Conviction
ACTIVE TRADING
Liquidity Grade
A
24h Momentum
—
Scarcity Index▲
90/100
UNICORN⚡
TOTAL GRADED1
9.8+ COUNT1
HIGH-GRADE RATIO (9.8+)100.0%
Price Anchors▲
SOVEREIGN (9.8 CGC)
$33.45
PRICE LADDER
9.8 FMV
$33.45
Anchor 9.8
$33.45
RAW
$5.40
PREMIUM STACK (VS 9.8)
10.0$43.00+28.6%
9.8$33.450.0%
9.2$19.01-43.2%
8.0$13.77-58.8%
Floor
$2.00
Ceiling
$43.00
Video Intelligence & Archival Media▲
Curated Market & Review Videos0 Verified Clips
Loading video intelligence…
◈Market MathCONFIRMED SALES ONLYPARTIAL▲
Momentum · ROC
Rate of Change
—
30d — · 120d —
Velocity Bands · 90D
Bollinger equivalent
Insufficient data
Grade Arbitrage
Max adjacent spread
WIDE
2050.0%
CGC 10.0 → 2.0 · 9 grades
Liquidity Conc. · HHI
Herfindahl-Hirschman
Insufficient data
Census Pressure · CPR
Pop. vs sales volume
Insufficient data
Price Efficiency · 90D
High/Low range ratio
STABLE
0.0%
$33.45 → $33.45 · 1pt
CONFIRMED SALES ONLY · NO AI · NO CATALOG ESTIMATES · PEAK CGC RAW
News, record and sources
News linked to this book, the Grand Comics Database record, variants and the source of each figure.
Creative Production Team
GCD ARCHIVAL CREDITS
WRITER / SCRIPT
Greg Rucka
PENCILER / ARTIST
Pere Pérez
INKER
Pere Pérez
COLORIST
Mazi
LETTERER
typeset
EDITOR
Wil Moss
Price by gradeACA12
Grade
Panel Profits
10.0
$43.00
9.8
$33.45
9.2
$19.01
8.0
$13.77
6.0
$9.25
4.0
$3.38
3.0
$3.00
2.0
$2.00
Raw
$5.40
Sovereign Equity ClearinghouseMacro Benchmarking: CE70-ACT12
In the past on Krypton, Ursa leads the Black Zero unit as Kandor is being taken by Brainiac. Ak-Var and his wife Tes are a part of the unit, and concerned because their daughter Thara is there. They locate her as one of the people that Brainiac is rounding up into the middle of the city, but the unit is taken down. A wounded Ursa and Thara watch from opposite sides as a bottle is formed around the middle of the city, killing Thara's parents. Kandor is now in Brainiac's ship, but ignored until Argo City is later discovered in space, and its people, including Zor-El and Alura, are added to Kandor. As they knew Thara and they miss their daughter, they form a family. Years later, after Chris Kent has sacrificed himself into the Phantom Zone at the end of the Phantom Zone invasion of Earth, he undergoes an abnormal growth spurt. He returns to Fort Rozz, and hides there with the help of Non. Back in Kandor, Thara has joined the military guild, but then gets invited to join the religious guild, and becomes a monk. In Fort Rozz, Chris sneaks into Zod's lab, and sees Superman and Lois on a monitor, and tries to contact them using some Brainiac technology. Instead, it forms a painful connection between Chris and Thara. Chris is revealed by his pain. Thara can no longer be a monk, she returns to Zor-El and Alura, and has an obsession to go to the Phantom Zone and get Chris. She finally armors up and goes there, but is almost thwarted by Non. But he takes pity on them, and, having stolen the projector, projects them back to Kandor, and destroys the projector.
The recovery of third-party encapsulation and grading expenditures when an asset is acquired at a discount below the physical cost of replacement grading fees, shipping, and insurance.
Direct Asset Application (Action Comics Annual #12):Standard third-party slabbing fees and insurance average $45–$65 per book. At an entry valuation of $33.45, the grading expense represents a substantial built-in subsidy, providing downside protection against raw comic volatility.
Modeled Dealer Bid$24.08Wholesale Buy-List Floor
Retail Ask Price$38.47Top Dealer Catalog Asking
Bid-Ask Spread37%Market Liquidity Margin
Downside Cushion28%Protection from Wholesale Floor
Story Title: "The Origin of Nightwing and Flamebird!"
Flamebird
Years ago on Krypton, the alien conqueror Brainiac came to the planet intent on assimilating the world's capitol city of Kandor. A Kryptonian Black Zero unit led by Lt. Ursa was dispatched to respond to the crisis. As the Brainiac Probes began slaughtering soldiers, Ursa lost her nerve and was crippled with fear as two of her aspirants Ak-Var and his wife Tes Ak-Var were murdered before her eyes. Ak-Var's young daughter Thara witnessed the carnage, but was trapped behind the force field surrounding the city. Brainiac uprooted Kandor from the planet, miniaturized it, and placed it within his ship's laboratory for future observation.
In the years following Krypton's destruction, Brainiac came upon the surviving floating community of Argo City. He assimilated Argo City with Kandor and Thara Ak-Var met Alura and Zor-El. The Els took Thara into their home and treated her as one of their family. Thara grew very close with their daughter Kara.
As she grew older, Thara began having prophetic dreams of a legendary Kryptonian creature known as the Flamebird. These dreams drove her to join the Kryptonian Religious Guild and she became a devout worshiper of Rao. While living with the other guild members, Thara continued to have dreams. She dreamed of a boy conceived and born in the Phantom Zone and knew that it was her destiny to meet with him. She quit the Religious Guild and returned to Zor-El and Alura. They decided to place her in charge of the Kryptonian Defense Council. Thara knew that this would help her in her search for this mysterious child from the Phantom Zone. With access to nearly any military equipment she could find, Thara donned a suit of armor and a miniature Phantom Zone Projector and journeyed into the Phantom Zone. She soon united with the boy from her dreams -- Lor-Zod. Lor-Zod was the son of General Zod and her parents' former commander, Lt. Ursa. Held prisoner inside of a material anomaly called Fort Rozz, Thara freed Lor-Zod and escaped from the Phantom Zone. Together, they assumed the costumed identities of Flamebird and Nightwing.
Nightwing
Though not of Krypton, Lor-Zod's (aka, Christopher Kent) origins are steeped in Kryptonian history. Prior to the destruction of Krypton, the Kryptonian prison known as Fort Rozz was the scene of a massive riot, one that resulted in an exploding Phantom Zone projector that shunted the entire facility into the Phantom Zone. The wraith-like Zoners who already existed there found that Fort Rozz existed in a null pocket where they could regain their material forms. The criminals slaughtered all of the prison guards and took control of the fort.
This enabled General Zod and Ursa to conceive a child, Lor-Zod. Due to the unconventional nature of the Phantom Zone, as well as the unique nature of his conception, Lor-Zod was able to maintain his corporeal form. This proved to be more of a curse than a benefit as he could feel the coldness of the Zone itself as well as pangs of hunger -- traits that the other Zoners were immune to due to their insubstantial nature.
Zod and Ursa regularly abused Lor-Zod and used him as a tool in order to escape the Phantom Zone. The only Zoner who restrained from visiting these cruelties upon Lor-Zod was the addle-brained Non. Whereas the others showed the child nothing but hate, Non showed him kindness.
Lor-Zod was present when the Zoners attempted to take control of Metropolis. It was at this time that Lor-Zod met Superman who treated him as a true son and gave him the human name Christopher Kent. Inspired by Superman's selflessness and heroism, Lor-Zod sacrificed his own freedom in order to return the Kryptonian terrorists back to the Phantom Zone.
Back in the Zone, Lor-Zod fled from his parents and hid inside the smaller ducts and catacombs of Fort Rozz. It was at this time that he began having inexplicable growth spurts, rapidly aging to that of a teenager.
He discovered some reverse-engineered Brainiac technology that had been left behind from when the fort was still on Krypton and realized that his parents were using it to plan their next escape. Lor-Zod donned a headband from one of the probes and this created a psionic link with Thara Ak-Var. Shortly thereafter, Thara Ak-Var appeared in the Phantom Zone and united with Lor. Using a miniaturized Phantom Zone Projector, they were able to escape the zone together.
16 Canonical Collectible Asset Classes Matrix
Valuation parity across physical collectible manifestations for Action Comics Annual #12.
SOVHIGH
Certified Universal Slab
CGC, CBCS, PSA Universal certified high-grade specimens (9.8 / 9.6 / 9.4). The gold standard for institutional alternative investment.
1.00x Base$33
Role: Core Market Baseline
SIGMEDIUM
Witnessed Signature Series
Official witnessed creator-signed slabs (Yellow label). Valued based on creator historical stature and inscription provenance.
1.50x Premium$50
Role: Creator Provenance Alpha
PEDINSTITUTIONAL
Recognized Pedigree Collection
Certified specimens from landmark historical collections (Edgar Church / Mile High, White Mountain, Kansas City, Pacific Coast).
3.00x Historical Grail$100
Role: Sovereign Heritage Grail
NEWHIGH
Newsstand Distributor Edition
Original newsstand barcode distribution copies. Extremely scarce in high grade due to newsstand rack wear and unsold return pulping.
1.35x Scarcity$45
Role: Scarcity Multiplier
PRVMEDIUM
Regional Price Test Variant
Regional price test market copies (Canadian 75¢/95¢ variants, Marvel 30¢/35¢ test variants). Highly coveted micro-population rarities.
2.50x Asymmetry$84
Role: Census Asymmetry
RATHIGH
Retailer Ratio Incentive Variant
Exclusively allocated copies requiring retailer orders of 1:25, 1:50, 1:100, or 1:500 standard copies. Immediate manufactured scarcity.
1.75x Allocation$59
Role: Modern Velocity Float
RAWHIGH
Raw / Uncertified Specimen
Unslabbed collector copies inspected under standard Overstreet physical guidelines. The primary pool for grading arbitrage.
0.35x Arbitrage Base$12
Role: Grading Arbitrage Pipeline
VARHIGH
Cover Art / Foil / Virgin Edition
Alternative artistic interpretations, virgin covers, metal foil, and convention exclusives with dedicated collector followings.
1.25x Aesthetic$42
Role: Aesthetic Collector Demand
DIRHIGH
Direct Market Comic Shop Edition
Standard specialty comic shop printings sold through non-returnable distribution. The baseline circulation foundation.
1.00x Standard Float$33
Role: Circulation Float
QLFMEDIUM
Certified Qualified Label
Green label copies with significant manufacturing flaws, unwitnessed signatures, or missing coupons that do not affect the main story.
0.50x Qualified$17
Role: Affordable Grail Access
RSTMEDIUM
Certified Restored Specimen
Purple label copies with professional or amateur color touch, tear seals, piece fill, or spine rebuilds.
0.40x Conservation$13
Role: Conservation Specimen
CNSMEDIUM
Certified Conserved Specimen
Blue/Grey label copies treated exclusively with archival preservation techniques (leaf-casting, rice paper tear reinforcement, solvent wash).
0.70x Archival$23
Role: Museum Preservation
PRNHIGH
Subsequent Official Printing
Official second, third, or later printings released to satisfy secondary market sellouts. Distinct cover art and trade dress.
0.65x Repress$22
Role: Secondary Sellout Wave
INTSPECIALIZED
Foreign Market / Translated Edition
International editions licensed by La Prensa (Mexico), Editora Abril (Brazil), Panini (Europe), or Titan (UK).
Advance promotional black-and-white booklets, ashcans created to secure trademark rights, and preview giveaways.
4.00x Pre-Publication$134
Role: Pre-Publication History
Atomic Tradeable Instruments: Published Variants & Printings
1 PUBLISHED EDITIONS
GCD Canon
Each cover variant, retailer incentive, and subsequent printing represents an independent atomic tradeable instrument with unique supply elasticity, barcode registration, and secondary market demand.
Inspect underlying sources, timestamps, and confidence factors for any market claim
FULL AUDITABILITY
SELECT CLAIM TO INSPECT:
INSPECTING CLAIM / SIGNAL
PriceCharting & Exchange Market Pricing = $33.45
FRESHNESS: 2026-10-06
98% CONFIDENCE
WHY PANEL PROFITS BELIEVES THIS CLAIM:
All prices are current market price based on historic completed sales with a buyer and seller agreeing on price. Calculated via proprietary algorithm tracking end-of-month historical sales. Unsold items are excluded.
CORROBORATING SOURCE OBSERVATIONS (3)
PriceCharting (Historical Sales Model)Prices calculated using proprietary algorithm from completed transactions only (buyer and seller agreed price; unsold listings excluded). End-of-month historic tracking across Ungraded, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 8.0, 9.0, 9.2, 9.8, and 10.0.
2026-10-06VERIFIED
Panel Profits Sovereign Order BookVerified valuation anchor at $33.45 with recorded transaction history
2026-10-06VERIFIED
CGC / GoCollect Census CorroborationCensus corroboration across certified slabs: 1 graded copies recorded
2026-10-09T05:49:57.53+00:00CORROBORATED
Sources
PriceCharting via Panel Profits
9.8 price = $33.45
As of 2026-10-06
Stored PriceCharting 9.8 price for product 3344969. 1 dated nightly snapshot on file for this book.
Stored rows
PriceCharting$33.45
2026-10-06
Characters: Flamebird, Nightwing, Alura-El, Superman, Zor-El, Phantom Zone Criminals, General Zod, Dev-Em, Non, Ursa
Black Zero [UrsaAk-Var (intro, death)Tes Ak-Var (intro, death)] (intro)Thara Ak-Var [Flamebird]Zor-ElAluraChris Kent [Nightwing]SupermanNonGeneral ZodLois Lane (on monitor)Dev-Em
In the past on Krypton, Ursa leads the Black Zero unit as Kandor is being taken by Brainiac. Ak-Var and his wife Tes are a part of the unit, and concerned because their daughter Thara is there. They locate her as one of the people that Brainiac is rounding up into the middle of the city, but the unit is taken down. A wounded Ursa and Thara watch from opposite sides as a bottle is formed around the middle of the city, killing Thara's parents. Kandor is now in Brainiac's ship, but ignored until Argo City is later discovered in space, and its people, including Zor-El and Alura, are added to Kandor. As they knew Thara and they miss their daughter, they form a family. Years later, after Chris Kent has sacrificed himself into the Phantom Zone at the end of the Phantom Zone invasion of Earth, he undergoes an abnormal growth spurt. He returns to Fort Rozz, and hides there with the help of Non. Back in Kandor, Thara has joined the military guild, but then gets invited to join the religious guild, and becomes a monk. In Fort Rozz, Chris sneaks into Zod's lab, and sees Superman and Lois on a monitor, and tries to contact them using some Brainiac technology. Instead, it forms a painful connection between Chris and Thara. Chris is revealed by his pain. Thara can no longer be a monk, she returns to Zor-El and Alura, and has an obsession to go to the Phantom Zone and get Chris. She finally armors up and goes there, but is almost thwarted by Non. But he takes pity on them, and, having stolen the projector, projects them back to Kandor, and destroys the projector.
Red Cirle Has Arrived
5 pages
Featured Characters & Entities
HangmanInfernoThe ShieldThe Web
This is some way to kick off the summer, isn't it? [June 17, 2009]
1 pages
Featured Characters & Entities
Batgirl
House Advertisement
1 pages
Ads
4 pages
Cartoon Network This Summer
8 pages
Collectible Due Diligence Dossier
“The Origin of Nightwing and Flamebird!”
VERIFIED LORE
Iconic Climax DialogueMediaWiki Canon
“We are the best Krypton has to offer! We are Krypton's sword and shield! General Zod sends us because we will get the job done! Nor for him, not for the council, but for our people!”
=== Flamebird ===
Years ago on Krypton, the alien conqueror Brainiac) came to the planet intent on assimilating the world's capitol city of Kandor. A Kryptonian Black Zero unit led by Lt. Ursa) was dispatched to respond to the crisis. As the Brainiac Probes began slaughtering soldiers, Ursa lost her nerve and was crippled with fear as two of her aspirants Ak-Var) and his wife Tes Ak-Var) were murdered before her eyes. Ak-Var's young daughter Thara) witnessed the carnage, but was trapped behind the force field surrounding the city. Brainiac uprooted Kandor from the planet, miniaturized it, and placed it within his ship's laboratory for future observation.
In the years following Krypton's destruction, Brainiac came upon the surviving floating community of Argo City. He assimilated Argo City with Kandor and Thara Ak-Var met ) and ). The Els took Thara into their home and treated her as one of their family. Thara grew very close with their daughter ).
As she grew older, Thara began having prophetic dreams of a legendary Kryptonian creature known as the Flamebird. These dreams drove her to join the Kryptonian Religious Guild and she became a devout worshiper of Rao). While living with the other guild members, Thara continued to have dreams. She dreamed of a boy conceived and born in the Phantom Zone and knew that it was her destiny to meet with him. She quit the Religious Guild and returned to Zor-El and Alura. They decided to place her in charge of the Kryptonian Defense Council. Thara knew that this would help her in her search for this mysterious child from the Phantom Zone. With access to nearly any military equipment she could find, Thara donned a suit of armor and a miniature Phantom Zone Projector and journeyed into the Phantom Zone. She soon united with the boy from her dreams -- Lor-Zod). Lor-Zod was the son of General Zod and her parents' former commander, Lt. Ursa. Held prisoner inside of a material anomaly called Fort Rozz, Thara freed Lor-Zod and escaped from the Phantom Zone. Together, they assumed the costumed identities of Flamebird and Nightwing.
Price Evidence & Market Order Book by Grade Tier
VERIFIED EVIDENCE ENGINE
Recorded price evidence by source and grade tier. Ungraded / RAW pricing represents loose physical copies; certified grading authorities record authenticated slabbed grades only. Unpriced grades remain unpriced.
26 grade tiers · Multi-source market ladder5 Active Authority Streams
Continuous Market Execution Ladderbid/ask depth
UngradedRAW
Loose / Raw
$5.40
Bid: $1.20Ask: $5.89
4.0 / VG4.0
Very Good
$3.38
Bid: —Ask: —
6.0 / Fine6.0
Fine
$9.25
Bid: $2.00Ask: $9.99
8.0 / VF8.0
Very Fine
$13.77
Bid: —Ask: —
9.2 / NM-9.2
Near Mint -
$19.01
Bid: —Ask: —
9.89.8
Near Mint / Mint5 tracked sales
$33.45
Bid: —Ask: —
Cross-Authority Evidence Registry· Full Continuous Multi-Tier Matrix
Ladder View:
Authority Source / Metric
RAWUNGRADED
1.8
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
9.2
9.6
9.8ANCHOR
10.0
Panel Profits(Exchange FMV)
$5.40
—
$3.00
$3.38
—
$9.25
—
$13.77
—
$19.01
$32.00
$33.45
$43.00
Panel Profits(Bid (Buy Price))
$1.20
—
—
—
—
$2.00
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Panel Profits(Ask (Sell Price))
$5.89
—
—
—
—
$9.99
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Panel Profits(Annual Volume)
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
5 tracked sales
—
Panel Profits(Realized Listings)
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
5 sold
—
Active Ladder Scope:13 of 26 Tiers Shown (RAW → 10.0)
Unrecorded on file:Exchange Benchmark IndexComicBaseCGC · GPACBCSPSAPGXEGS / EGAeBay SoldGoCollect
Highest Graded Market Price
$43.00(Grade 10.0)
Highest verified price observed. Non-9.8 books never receive a 9.8 price or synthetic valuation.
ComicBase Reference Guide
—
ComicBase catalog guide reference valuation. Evaluated independently from newsstand cover prices and certified slabs.
Original Stamped Cover Price
—
Historical cover price stamped on physical newsstand or direct copies at initial publication.
Translation Layer & Strict Isolation
Panel Profits decodes auction transaction feeds into sovereign econometric market valuations and bid-ask spreads. CGC, CBCS, and PSA never carry RAW prices.