Stored prices by grade and source, exactly as recorded. A source with no price for a grade shows a dash.
Your holding and stored prices
Your cost basis next to the stored PriceCharting price for the grade you hold
Unheld Asset
Portfolio Holdings & Cost-Basis Ledger
Personal Verified Position
No Holding Logged in Portfolio
Track your holding in your portfolio. Record your grade (0.5–10.0 or Raw), grading authority (CGC, CBCS, PSA, or Raw), acquisition cost basis, and purchase date to activate real-time equity valuation, unrealized ROI, and capital gains tracking.
Sovereign Storage: Supabase RLS ProtectedStatus: Unheld
Stored prices
PriceCharting
Grade 9.8 Benchmark
$442.00
Dealer buy: — / Retail sell: —
RAW / Ungraded FMV
$32.55
Dealer buy: $14.40 / Retail sell: $35.99
Market Velocity
—
Original Cover: —
Price history and sales
Dated PriceCharting snapshots and recorded sales. Nothing is drawn where no dated price exists.
Watchlist
Key Prices
SOV Price$442.00
9.8 FMV$442.00
RAW$32.55
24h Δ↓ -92.8%
Grade Spread
10.0
$575.00—
9.8
$442.002
9.6
$122.001
9.4
$50.00—
RAW
$32.55—
price · vol
Census Snapshot
1,022
total graded
443
9.8+
9.8
443
9.6
262
9.4
141
9.2
67
9
40
8.5
38
CGC Universal + SS · Oct 2026
Intelligence Feed
No recent stories
AI-scored · tracking Action Comics · refreshes every 2 min
A pricing discrepancy between an auction listing and the prevailing cleared consensus value across organized exchanges, allowing rapid liquidity capture before market equilibrium reconverges.
Direct Asset Application (Action Comics #9):Dealer bids clear at $318.24 against a retail ask of $508.30 (37% spread). Purchasing near or below the wholesale floor allows immediate liquidation into dealer networks or secondary exchange rails with minimal duration risk.
Modeled Dealer Bid$318.24Wholesale Buy-List Floor
Retail Ask Price$508.30Top Dealer Catalog Asking
Bid-Ask Spread37%Market Liquidity Margin
Downside Cushion28%Protection from Wholesale Floor
After defeating Lex Luthor, Superman of Earth 23 determines that the need for the protection of a Warsuit suggests that his foe was working on something big. Investigating, he discovers a red and green object. The object seems to be producing music, "ringing out at impossibly oblique frequencies".
An armed woman with an eye-patch leaps through the tesseract. Disoriented, she considers Superman a possible threat and fires her weapon at him, only to discover that he is immune to her K-Laser – a weapon from Earth 36 which generates a beam of concentrated hate. Looking behind her, the woman realizes that her two companions Clark Kent and Jimmy Olsen have been severely burnt; Jimmy is dead. She explains that by passing through the tesseract, they have proved that there are multiple earths, each bearing its own watered down version of Superman. She wonders what makes this one so special.
Kalel explains that he came from a world called Krypton, which was doomed to destruction. His parents Jorel and Lara had placed their infant son into a prototype rocket, and sent him to Earth. He was found by a caring family, and grew to become known as Calvin Ellis — the President of the United States of America, and Superman.
The woman is Lois Lane, and she explains that there will be no time to save her dying companion Clark, as something is pursuing them. She mourns that their entire calamity was born of Clark's dream to change the world. It was he who had travelled in the east and returned with knowledge of the — the concept of creating a living thought with its own independent existence. Lois and Jimmy were drawn in by their curiosity, and together the three of them created a device that could make their thoughts realities — until they took it too far.
Together, they had decided to use the device to imagine a messiah, powered by thought, and capable of saving the world. They named this creation Superman. Over the course of his 25 minutes of existence, he outlined a code of ethics so profound and pure that the trio wept — but they were unable to retain his words after his departure. Realizing that they needed a way to make him more real, they shopped their idea around for funding in order to perfect their device, and approached Overcorp and it's mysterious CEO. However, they soured on the idea of allowing a corporation to control their device — but the idea of a Superman was too compelling, and eventually, they sold out.
Overcorp created something completely different from what Lois, Jimmy and Clark had intended — with the company's executives dreaming in unison to conceive of a figure capable of achieving maximum appeal, what was once a Superman was transformed into a violent and troubled, faceless anti-hero. This new Superman would become a globally recognized brand, used by Overcorp as a stepping stone to practical planetary domination.
Meanwhile, Clark discovered that the device could tap into the sounds coming from what had to have been other universes. They managed to jump between worlds, but the Superman that they had helped to create would pursue them and cause devastation in each new world. Lois had witnessed this Superman kill and devour a Superman analogue from another Earth known as Optiman, and destroy the Li'l League. Soon, Lois' Superman begins to emerge from the tesseract and announces its intention to kill its pretenders; Calvin promises to put an end to Superdoom here and now.
Asking Brainiac to cover for him at the White House, Superman proceeds to attack the monstrous creature that followed Lois, but is beaten back. However, there is one man on this Earth who is perfectly equipped to fight a fascistic reflection of Superman: Lex Luthor. Using the specialized K-Laser, Luthor blasts the imposing Superman in the face. Kalel recovers and offers his help. He knocks the Superman into the Transmitter Array tessaract, and traps him there between frequencies.
In the aftermath, the Justice League arrives to help clean up the mess and investigate the mysteries of the Transmatter Symphonic Array, as Luthor called it. Superman offers Lois shelter in his home and vows to help heal Clark, who may yet survive. Lois remarks Kalel might just be Superman done right.
16 Canonical Collectible Asset Classes Matrix
Valuation parity across physical collectible manifestations for Action Comics #9.
SOVHIGH
Certified Universal Slab
CGC, CBCS, PSA Universal certified high-grade specimens (9.8 / 9.6 / 9.4). The gold standard for institutional alternative investment.
1.00x Base$442
Role: Core Market Baseline
SIGMEDIUM
Witnessed Signature Series
Official witnessed creator-signed slabs (Yellow label). Valued based on creator historical stature and inscription provenance.
1.50x Premium$663
Role: Creator Provenance Alpha
PEDINSTITUTIONAL
Recognized Pedigree Collection
Certified specimens from landmark historical collections (Edgar Church / Mile High, White Mountain, Kansas City, Pacific Coast).
3.00x Historical Grail$1,326
Role: Sovereign Heritage Grail
NEWHIGH
Newsstand Distributor Edition
Original newsstand barcode distribution copies. Extremely scarce in high grade due to newsstand rack wear and unsold return pulping.
1.35x Scarcity$597
Role: Scarcity Multiplier
PRVMEDIUM
Regional Price Test Variant
Regional price test market copies (Canadian 75¢/95¢ variants, Marvel 30¢/35¢ test variants). Highly coveted micro-population rarities.
2.50x Asymmetry$1,105
Role: Census Asymmetry
RATHIGH
Retailer Ratio Incentive Variant
Exclusively allocated copies requiring retailer orders of 1:25, 1:50, 1:100, or 1:500 standard copies. Immediate manufactured scarcity.
1.75x Allocation$774
Role: Modern Velocity Float
RAWHIGH
Raw / Uncertified Specimen
Unslabbed collector copies inspected under standard Overstreet physical guidelines. The primary pool for grading arbitrage.
0.35x Arbitrage Base$155
Role: Grading Arbitrage Pipeline
VARHIGH
Cover Art / Foil / Virgin Edition
Alternative artistic interpretations, virgin covers, metal foil, and convention exclusives with dedicated collector followings.
1.25x Aesthetic$553
Role: Aesthetic Collector Demand
DIRHIGH
Direct Market Comic Shop Edition
Standard specialty comic shop printings sold through non-returnable distribution. The baseline circulation foundation.
1.00x Standard Float$442
Role: Circulation Float
QLFMEDIUM
Certified Qualified Label
Green label copies with significant manufacturing flaws, unwitnessed signatures, or missing coupons that do not affect the main story.
0.50x Qualified$221
Role: Affordable Grail Access
RSTMEDIUM
Certified Restored Specimen
Purple label copies with professional or amateur color touch, tear seals, piece fill, or spine rebuilds.
0.40x Conservation$177
Role: Conservation Specimen
CNSMEDIUM
Certified Conserved Specimen
Blue/Grey label copies treated exclusively with archival preservation techniques (leaf-casting, rice paper tear reinforcement, solvent wash).
0.70x Archival$309
Role: Museum Preservation
PRNHIGH
Subsequent Official Printing
Official second, third, or later printings released to satisfy secondary market sellouts. Distinct cover art and trade dress.
0.65x Repress$287
Role: Secondary Sellout Wave
INTSPECIALIZED
Foreign Market / Translated Edition
International editions licensed by La Prensa (Mexico), Editora Abril (Brazil), Panini (Europe), or Titan (UK).
Advance promotional black-and-white booklets, ashcans created to secure trademark rights, and preview giveaways.
4.00x Pre-Publication$1,768
Role: Pre-Publication History
Atomic Tradeable Instruments: Published Variants & Printings
5 PUBLISHED EDITIONS
GCD Canon
Each cover variant, retailer incentive, and subsequent printing represents an independent atomic tradeable instrument with unique supply elasticity, barcode registration, and secondary market demand.
Foreign editions (licensed through Panini, Urban Comics, Editorial Novaro, Novedades, Otto Simon, etc.) represent physical tradeable instruments in international secondary markets. Geographic scarcity and currency differentials drive global cross-border arbitrage.
This Looks Like a Job for Superman... ...of Earth 23!
1 pages
Featured Characters & Entities
Superman [President Calvin EllisKalel] (Earth-23)
The Curse of Superman
20 pages
Featured Characters & Entities
Superman [President Calvin EllisKalel] (Earth-23, origin)Brainiac (Earth-23, a computer)Justice League [Batman (Earth-23)
INSPECTABLE PROVENANCE & DATA AUDIT TRAIL
Inspect underlying sources, timestamps, and confidence factors for any market claim
FULL AUDITABILITY
SELECT CLAIM TO INSPECT:
INSPECTING CLAIM / SIGNAL
PriceCharting & Exchange Market Pricing = $442.00
FRESHNESS: 2026-10-06
98% CONFIDENCE
WHY PANEL PROFITS BELIEVES THIS CLAIM:
All prices are current market price based on historic completed sales with a buyer and seller agreeing on price. Calculated via proprietary algorithm tracking end-of-month historical sales. Unsold items are excluded.
CORROBORATING SOURCE OBSERVATIONS (3)
PriceCharting (Historical Sales Model)Prices calculated using proprietary algorithm from completed transactions only (buyer and seller agreed price; unsold listings excluded). End-of-month historic tracking across Ungraded, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 8.0, 9.0, 9.2, 9.8, and 10.0.
2026-10-06VERIFIED
Panel Profits Sovereign Order BookVerified valuation anchor at $442.00 with recorded transaction history
2026-10-06VERIFIED
CGC / GoCollect Census CorroborationCensus corroboration across certified slabs: 1022 graded copies recorded
2026-10-09T05:49:57.53+00:00CORROBORATED
Sources
PriceCharting via Panel Profits
9.8 price = $442.00
As of 2026-10-06
Stored PriceCharting 9.8 price for product 3464602. 1 dated nightly snapshot on file for this book.
Stored rows
PriceCharting$442.00
2026-10-06
Characters: Superman (Calvin Ellis), Lois Lane, Clark Kent, Jimmy Olsen, Courtney, Brainiac, Superdoom, Lex Luthor, Overcorp, Vyndktvx
After defeating Lex Luthor, Superman of Earth 23 determines that the need for the protection of a Warsuit suggests that his foe was working on something big. Investigating, he discovers a red and green object. The object seems to be producing music, "ringing out at impossibly oblique frequencies".
An armed woman with an eye-patch leaps through the tesseract. Disoriented, she considers Superman a possible threat and fires her weapon at him, only to discover that he is immune to her K-Laser – a weapon from Earth 36 which generates a beam of concentrated hate. Looking behind her, the woman realizes that her two companions Clark Kent and Jimmy Olsen have been severely burnt; Jimmy is dead. She explains that by passing through the tesseract, they have proved that there are multiple earths, each bearing its own watered down version of Superman. She wonders what makes this one so special.
Kalel explains that he came from a world called Krypton, which was doomed to destruction. His parents Jorel and Lara had placed their infant son into a prototype rocket, and sent him to Earth. He was found by a caring family, and grew to become known as Calvin Ellis — the President of the United States of America, and Superman.
The woman is Lois Lane, and she explains that there will be no time to save her dying companion Clark, as something is pursuing them. She mourns that their entire calamity was born of Clark's dream to change the world. It was he who had travelled in the east and returned with knowledge of the — the concept of creating a living thought with its own independent existence. Lois and Jimmy were drawn in by their curiosity, and together the three of them created a device that could make their thoughts realities — until they took it too far.
Together, they had decided to use the device to imagine a messiah, powered by thought, and capable of saving the world. They named this creation Superman. Over the course of his 25 minutes of existence, he outlined a code of ethics so profound and pure that the trio wept — but they were unable to retain his words after his departure. Realizing that they needed a way to make him more real, they shopped their idea around for funding in order to perfect their device, and approached Overcorp and it's mysterious CEO. However, they soured on the idea of allowing a corporation to control their device — but the idea of a Superman was too compelling, and eventually, they sold out.
Overcorp created something completely different from what Lois, Jimmy and Clark had intended — with the company's executives dreaming in unison to conceive of a figure capable of achieving maximum appeal, what was once a Superman was transformed into a violent and troubled, faceless anti-hero. This new Superman would become a globally recognized brand, used by Overcorp as a stepping stone to practical planetary domination.
Meanwhile, Clark discovered that the device could tap into the sounds coming from what had to have been other universes. They managed to jump between worlds, but the Superman that they had helped to create would pursue them and cause devastation in each new world. Lois had witnessed this Superman kill and devour a Superman analogue from another Earth known as Optiman, and destroy the Li'l League. Soon, Lois' Superman begins to emerge from the tesseract and announces its intention to kill its pretenders; Calvin promises to put an end to Superdoom here and now.
Asking Brainiac to cover for him at the White House, Superman proceeds to attack the monstrous creature that followed Lois, but is beaten back. However, there is one man on this Earth who is perfectly equipped to fight a fascistic reflection of Superman: Lex Luthor. Using the specialized K-Laser, Luthor blasts the imposing Superman in the face. Kalel recovers and offers his help. He knocks the Superman into the Transmitter Array tessaract, and traps him there between frequencies.
In the aftermath, the Justice League arrives to help clean up the mess and investigate the mysteries of the Transmatter Symphonic Array, as Luthor called it. Superman offers Lois shelter in his home and vows to help heal Clark, who may yet survive. Lois remarks Kalel might just be Superman done right.
At the White House, a meeting is in progress. Qurac — a Middle Eastern rogue nation — is on the brink of developing nuclear weapons, and the US Government needs to decide what to do next. It is hoped that over the course of his talks with the Quraci President, US President Calvin Ellis will be able to come to an agreement that would halt weapons development.
President-for-Life Harrat is expecting to be amused by Ellis' call, but he is soon confused by Ellis' intent to update him on the status of his own nuclear program. As it happens, Calvin is on a blue-tooth device, and — as Superman — has rendered all five of Harrat's underground Firestorm Labs non-functional. Two have caved in, one is filled with lava, one has suffered a core-breach, and the other simply doesn't work anymore.
Harrat declares the attack on his labs an act of war, but Ellis points out that having denied the existence of the plants, Harrat cannot openly admit that they were destroyed. He also points out that in the event of a war, Ellis' Alliance of Nations — which includes Atlantis, Markovia and Themyscira — certainly assure a regime-change in Qurac. Ellis offers peace and a place in the Alliance, whose medical technology and free trade would be of benefit to Harrat's people.
Hanging up from his phone call, Superman gets back to work at the fifth plant. Wonder Woman marvels at the contradiction: Calvin Ellis, a man of integrity, is secretly Superman, also a man of integrity, but is hiding this fact from everyone else and using his gifts to bend international law and cross borders at will. Superman argues that his actions, though shocking, are ultimately good. Wonder Woman points out that one day, even if his intentions are good, not everyone will necessarily agree.
Price Evidence & Market Order Book by Grade Tier
VERIFIED EVIDENCE ENGINE
Recorded price evidence by source and grade tier. Ungraded / RAW pricing represents loose physical copies; certified grading authorities record authenticated slabbed grades only. Unpriced grades remain unpriced.
26 grade tiers · Multi-source market ladder5 Active Authority Streams
Continuous Market Execution Ladderbid/ask depth
UngradedRAW
Loose / Raw
$32.55
Bid: $14.40Ask: $35.99
4.0 / VG4.0
Very Good
Unpriced
Bid: —Ask: —
6.0 / Fine6.0
Fine
Unpriced
Bid: —Ask: —
8.0 / VF8.0
Very Fine
Unpriced
Bid: —Ask: —
9.2 / NM-9.2
Near Mint -
Unpriced
Bid: —Ask: —
9.89.8
Near Mint / Mint1 tracked sales
$442.00
Bid: —Ask: —
Cross-Authority Evidence Registry· Full Continuous Multi-Tier Matrix
Ladder View:
Authority Source / Metric
RAWUNGRADED
1.8
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
9.2
9.6
9.8ANCHOR
10.0
Panel Profits(Exchange FMV)
$32.55
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
$122.00
$442.00
$575.00
Panel Profits(Bid (Buy Price))
$14.40
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Panel Profits(Ask (Sell Price))
$35.99
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Panel Profits(Annual Volume)
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
1 tracked sales
—
Panel Profits(Realized Listings)
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
1 sold
—
Active Ladder Scope:13 of 26 Tiers Shown (RAW → 10.0)
Unrecorded on file:Exchange Benchmark IndexComicBaseCGC · GPACBCSPSAPGXEGS / EGAeBay SoldGoCollect
Highest Graded Market Price
$575.00(Grade 10.0)
Highest verified price observed. Non-9.8 books never receive a 9.8 price or synthetic valuation.
ComicBase Reference Guide
—
ComicBase catalog guide reference valuation. Evaluated independently from newsstand cover prices and certified slabs.
Original Stamped Cover Price
—
Historical cover price stamped on physical newsstand or direct copies at initial publication.
Translation Layer & Strict Isolation
Panel Profits decodes auction transaction feeds into sovereign econometric market valuations and bid-ask spreads. CGC, CBCS, and PSA never carry RAW prices.