All-Star Comics #21

Price history & market evidence

Price observations belong to this edition. Guide estimates, catalog references and completed sales are separate kinds of evidence.

Reading this edition’s market

Compare the same cover, printing and grade before setting a bid. A raw guide or a higher-grade price does not establish a slab’s value. Include selling fees, shipping and the depth of completed-sale evidence when assessing an exit price.

The table includes 6 guide observations and 1 catalog references. These are reference values, not guaranteed sale proceeds.

Graded population

CGC records 88 graded copies for All Star Comics #21 (1944). Population is the number recorded by this grading source, not the total print run or all surviving copies.

Justice Society of America: "The Man Who Relived His Life, Introduction"

The Justice Society of America) reply to a summons to help Joe Fitch, an assistant to the distinguished Professor Everson. Joe is dying because he drank a fatal serum, an act that allowed the Professor to develop the cure for a life-threatening disease. On his deathbed, Joe tells the Justice Society members all the evil deeds he's regretted doing throughout his life. To fix Joe's regrets, Professor Everson dispatches the JSA members back through time to change history, by setting straight all the evil deeds in his past. | Appearing1 = **Featured Characters:** * Justice Society of America) ** Atom) ** Doctor Fate) ** Doctor Mid-Nite) ** Hawkman) ** Johnny Thunder) ** Sandman) ** Spectre) ** Starman) ** Wonder Woman) **Supporting Characters:** * Johnny's Thunderbolt) **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer2_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler2_1 = Sheldon Moldoff | Inker2_1 = Sheldon Moldoff | Letterer2_1 = | StoryTitle2 = Chapter 1: "Hawkman and Sapphire Slim Spears" | Synopsis2 = In order to repay gambling debts, Joe abused his position as a bank teller to help a gang rob his bank, but Hawkman) helps Joe beat up the gang and turn them over to the police. | Appearing2 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer3_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler3_1 = Joe Gallagher | Inker3_1 = Joe Gallagher | Letterer3_1 = | StoryTitle3 = Chapter 2: "The Sandman and Big Mike McCullum" | Synopsis3 = The Sandman) stops Joe from shooting his enemy in a crowded theater, although, due to the San Francisco earthquake, Joe was unaware at the time that he didn't actually kill anyone. | Appearing3 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer4_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler4_1 = Stan Aschmeier | Inker4_1 = Stan Aschmeier | Letterer4_1 = | StoryTitle4 = Chapter 3: "Starman and Pancho Villa" | Synopsis4 = After the shooting, Joe fled to Mexico, where he planned to dynamite a saloon to prove himself to some bandits. Starman) tries to talk Joe out of blowing up the building, but sabotages his dynamite, just to be safe. When the saloon blows up anyway, Starman finds the bandits who did it, but Joe had already fled. | Appearing4 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer5_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler5_1 = Stan Aschmeier | Inker5_1 = Stan Aschmeier | Letterer5_1 = | StoryTitle5 = Chapter 4: "Dr. Mid-Nite in WWI" | Synopsis5 = Joe then joins the military to fight in World War I, where he let his commanding officer die because he was too scared to act. Doctor Mid-Nite) is able to talk Joe through his fear and Joe takes action to save his C.O. | Appearing5 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer6_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler6_1 = Joe Kubert | Inker6_1 = Joe Kubert | Letterer6_1 = | StoryTitle6 = Chapter 5: "Dr. Fate and Al Crump" | Synopsis6 = Joe then takes a job working for rum-runners. The boss learns about Joe's past and tries to blackmail Joe into performing a murder for him. Joe intends to shoot the boss, before Doctor Fate) intervenes and helps Joe break up the entire gang. | Appearing6 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer7_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler7_1 = Stan Aschmeier | Inker7_1 = Stan Aschmeier | Letterer7_1 = | StoryTitle7 = Chapter 6: "Johnny Thunder and the Election Board" | Synopsis7 = Finally, to land a job, Joe helps a crooked politician rig an election. Johnny Thunder) get involved, however, and convinces Joe to do the right thing. Nevertheless, it's the Thunderbolt) that actually ensures the election is clean on election day. | Appearing7 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| Writer8_1 = Gardner Fox | Penciler8_1 = Joe Gallagher | Inker8_1 = Joe Gallagher | Letterer8_1 = | StoryTitle8 = Justice Society of America: "The Man Who Relived His Life, Conclusion" | Synopsis8 = Their individual missions complete, the Justice Society members returns to the present. One by one, they tell Joe what really happened in his past and Joe Fitch passes away, content to know he was never as evil as he imagined himself to be. | Appearing8 = **Featured Characters:** * **Supporting Characters:** * **Antagonists:** * **Other Characters:** * **Locations:** * **Items:** * **Vehicles:** *

| StoryTitle21 = Hop Harrigan: "Express to Berlin" | Synopsis21 = Hop Harrigan) and Tank Tinker) are ferrying poison gas from London to Tunis, when they spot six Nazi fighters, however, only one engages them. Quickly, the other five pilots shoot down their comrade. Hop and Tank are puzzled, until an armed German spy with stolen British intelligence hijacks the plane and demand Hop flies him to Berlin. Hop and Tank, working together trick the spy, and shatter a vial of the gas to kill the spy. | Appearing21 = **Featured Characters:** * Hop Harrigan) **Supporting Characters:** * Tank Tinker) **Antagonists:** * Chambers * Nazis **Other Characters:** * Arthur Stacey * Colonel Leigh **Locations:** * Berlin * London * Tunis **Items:** * **Vehicles:** * Messerschmitt Bf 109 * North American B-25 Mitchell

| Notes = * Published quarterly by All-American Comics, Inc. * Reprinted in All-Star Comics Archives Vol. 5 (Collected). * Professor Everson) is revealed, in this story, to have been a member of the Time Trust from All-Star Comics Vol 1 10. * Sandman and Dr. Fate appear in the framing prologue and epilogue chapters only. After this issue, both heroes will be dropped from the series without comment. Thus, this issue is the final Golden Age appearance with the JSA for both of them. * Wonder Woman again appears in the Introduction but not in the Conclusion.

| Trivia = | Recommended = | Links =

Creative credits

Writers: Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox, Gardner Fox

Interior art: Joe Gallagher, Sheldon Moldoff, Joe Gallagher, Stan Aschmeier, Stan Aschmeier, Joe Kubert, Stan Aschmeier, Joe Gallagher

Source records & attribution

Panel Profits keeps each source identity attached to its edition record.

COMICBASE: comicbase:44422

GCD: 3691

PANEL PROFITS: 2335739