DC·Batman Annual·#4·Silver Age·ID-2423607
| Grade | Census & Float Distribution | Copies / Slabs | Role | FMV | Sales | Total Value | Multiple |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9.8 | 1 of 81 slabs (1.2%) | 1 | SOV | $3,577.85 | — | $3,578 | (143.8x) |
| 9.6 | 2 of 81 slabs (2.5%) | 2 | $3,936.00 | — | $7,872 | (158.2x) | |
| 9.4 | 2 of 81 slabs (2.5%) | 2 | — | — | — | (2.5%) | |
| 9.2 | 1 of 81 slabs (1.2%) | 1 | $528.42 | — | $528.42 | (21.2x) | |
| 9.0 | 10 of 81 slabs (12.3%) | 10 | $76.00 | — | $760.00 | (3.1x) | |
| 7.0 | 13 of 81 slabs (16.0%) | 13 | ANC | $61.00 | — | $793.00 | (2.5x) |
| RAW | Raw Uncertified Copies | — | RAW | $24.88 | — | — | (1.0x Base) |
Empirical cash settlement intelligence, cross-grade elasticity curve, and secondary liquidation velocity.
Empirical step multipliers between adjacent condition tiers. Pinpoints the exponential premium transition and capital efficiency frontier.
Realized turnover cadence and capital absorption depth across certified auction comps.
Autonomous institutional strategies, financial equilibrium, scarcity modeling, and algorithmic risk profiling.
Market operates purely on organic buyer and seller auction discovery. Zero artificial price interventions or emergency liquidity halts on record.
Verified historical transaction line with quarterly equilibrium baseline anchor.
Understand how physical sales, invested dollars, and liquidity friction divide across grades.
Historical price records
Relative market value allocation
Estimated execution friction
Bibliographic provenance, creator credits, historical significance, and multimedia documentation.
Bill Finger
Sheldon Moldoff
Stan Kaye
Whitney Ellsworth, Jack Schiff
Home of Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and the Justice League.
Marvel revolution. Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, and Steve Ditko create the modern superhero. Spider-Man, Fantastic Four, X-Men debut.
The sweet spot for collectors — significant enough to be culturally important, scarce enough to be valuable. 9.8 copies are extremely rare.
Silver Age (1956–1970) — the era that redefined the superhero genre. Scientific themes, moral complexity, and Stan Lee's Marvel revolution define this period. High-grade copies command aggressive premiums.
Inspectable mathematical proof, blockchain/ledger provenance, data integrity validation, and asset taxonomy.
In illiquid alternative asset markets, sovereign blue-chip holdings trade at an exponential multiple over mid-grade float due to institutional accumulation and inelastic seller reservation prices.
Bruce Wayne is pleased that a newcomer, Kathy Kane, has taken such a liking to the Batman. However, when a mysterious new crimefighter appears on the scene, usurping much of Batman's glory, the Dynamic Duo steps in to halt her career before she gets seriously hurt.
Each cover variant, retailer incentive, and subsequent printing represents an independent atomic tradeable instrument with unique supply elasticity, barcode registration, and secondary market demand.
Strict algorithmic segregation separating clean single-issue Cover A sales from multi-issue lot bundles, retailer exclusives, and foreign variants.

Batman Annual #7
9.8
$15,600.00
9.6
—
9.4
—
RAW
$12.74

Batman Annual #2
9.8
$11,400.00
9.6
—
9.4
—
RAW
$35.00

Batman Annual #1
9.8
$7,610.84
9.6
—
9.4
—
RAW
$42.22

Batman Annual #4
9.8
$3,569.21
9.6
—
9.4
—
RAW
$24.88

Batman Annual #3
9.8
$3,002.30
9.6
—
9.4
—
RAW
$20.24
The discovery of an old Batman-type costume in Bruce Wayne's attic re-opens the Wayne murder case, and helps him realize that Joey Chill had only been HIRED to kill his parents...and the real man responsible was still alive and free.
Batman wakes from a sound sleep to find himself in a mental ward, not realizing that a Professor Milo had given him a dose of amnesia gas that dulls the will to live.
Bruce Wayne is pleased that a newcomer, Kathy Kane, has taken such a liking to the Batman. However, when a mysterious new crimefighter appears on the scene, usurping much of Batman's glory, the Dynamic Duo steps in to halt her career before she gets seriously hurt.
Gotham City is shocked to see Robin drive up to Police HQ one day in a Robinmobile, and refuses to comment on the disappearance of his long-time partner in crime-fighting.
Batman is puzzled when a trophy of a case he just completed disappears and is replaced by another item...right in the confines of the Bat-Cave.
Bruce Wayne has been invited on a 3-day reunion cruise with some of his old college athletic team chums. But joy turns to fear when their host not only discovers Batman's true identity, but threatens to kill each and every one of them with planted mines.
Dick Grayson goes to sleep while Bruce is out on a date with Kathy, and dreams of the loss of their secret identities caused by Bruce and Kathy's marriage.
After battling Gorilla Hardy and his gang, the Dynamic Duo arrive back at the Bat-Cave, but Robin has a surprise for his caped counterpart: he is NOT Dick Grayson, but Fred Loyd, who assumed the role after Dick Grayson was injured.
Professor Milo decides to end the career of the Caped Crusader by giving him a phobia: the fear of bats!
“| Speaker =”
— | StoryTitle1 = Everyday.
| Appearing1 = Featured Characters: * Batman Supporting Characters: * Adrienne Williams * Alfred Pennyworth Antagonists: * The Cavalry Charge * Dragons * Harley Quinn * Henry Feder * The Joker * Kalibak * Mummies Nathan Yellin Red Racer * * Eric Yellin * Lena Yellin Mrs. Norris Tony Panza * * * ** * ** ** Robinson High School * * ** * * * Items:* * * * * * * * *
This entire issue was reprinted in DC Comics Classics Library: The Batman Annuals Vol. 2. Though pencil credits are listed in the comic as Bob Kane, it is Sheldon Moldoff who is "ghosting" for Bob.